Crocs remained down all day Tuesday after Crocs announced guidance cuts that one analyst termed "stunning," amid lower-than-expected demand, and Najarian warned investors to resist the temptation to bottom fish. Macke doesn’t have confidence in the company after the numbers it reported on Monday, and Finerman says management is clueless. None of the Fast Money guys are for this stock right now.

Crocs reduced its first-quarter outlook far below analyst expectations late Monday, citing weak sales and costs related to closing a Canadian manufacturing plant.